Question for Fantasy Gurus

[ex-Pittsburgh Pirates]

Looking for some advice in another league.

I have to choose keepers at the end of the year. I can keep 1 infielder, 1 outfielder, 1 pitcher, and 1 wild card.

Infielders:
C.Santana
A.Rizzo
D.Ortiz
M.Betts
Wong
T.Tulowitzki
E.Encarnacion

Outfielders:
B.Hamilton
M.Trout
A.McCutchen
JD Martinez

Pitchers:
M.Scherzer
C.Hamels
Jose Fernandez
Yu Darvish
F.Liriano
C.McHugh
P.Hughes
and a bunch of closers (I'm not keeping a closer.)


So, here's the plan:
IF - Tulowitzki (should I keep Encarnacion instead? Maybe even Santana? Tired of Tulo being hurt for the playoffs every year.)
OF - Trout (duh)
Wild Card - McCutchen
P - no freaking clue

My question is, which pitcher should I keep? I can make an argument for Darvish, Fernandez, or Scherzer. If all of them were healthy, I'd rank them Fernandez-Darvish-Scherzer. Problem is, only Scherzer is healthy. So maybe I should keep him? But Darvish should be ok for the start of the season, so maybe keep him? But Fernandez has the most upside? So maybe him? Or maybe I drop McCutchen and keep 2 of them?

Help me please. (We are passed the trade deadline, so trading is not an option.)

[Minnesota Twins]

I'd keep tulo still and prob go w scherzer myself although where he ends up as fa matters. Hope for an nl team signing him

[ex-Pittsburgh Pirates]

Tulo is great when he is healthy. But this is like the 30th season in a row that I'm left looking for a SS on waivers for the playoffs (Traded for Rollins, who got hurt right before playoffs. Now I had to pick up Betts).

I have no problem making the playoffs every year in this league. I've won the regular season 4 out of 6 years, with a 2nd place and a 4th place finish mixed in. Top 4 make the playoffs. So that's why I'm tempted to let Tulo go. That and the fact he was in a ton of trade rumors this year. I like him with the Rockies. Not so much with the Mets.

Since you are obviously the expertiest expert in this league (158 points? really?) I'm leaning to Scherzer.

Anyone else?

[LA Dodgers]

I like Encarnacion, trout and max sherzer

[ex-Pittsburgh Pirates]

A vote for EE. Interesting. But who should I take with my wildcard? (can be anybody...McCutchen I presume?)

[Minnesota Twins]

Quit trying to jinx me!

I would say McCutch as wildcard as having Trout and McCutch is pretty sweet of. If thinking of truly wild wildcard Hamilton gives big time steals.

[torontobluejays]

I'd say Rizzo, Trout, McCutheon (WC)and Scherzer.

[ex-Pittsburgh Pirates]

I may actually cut Hamilton before next week. The person I will probably play in the championship has me beat in steals no matter what and I'm already losing steals this week 3-0. May punt steals and use the lineup spot to stream starters.

[Detroit]

I would keep encarnacion as your infielder. Tulo is a huge injury risk.

As for pitchers, Scherzer is the standout, but Fernandez has bigger upside? But you know Scherzer is healthy and going to covet a huge contract this offseason from some team. If he stays in Detroit, it's the obvious pick because commerica is a big stadium.

Trout, mccutchen....can't argue with those guys.